Prop Trading is a cooperation model where a firm provides traders with capital to trade on financial markets. The main advantage of this solution is the ability to trade significant amounts without the need to invest personal funds. Traders receive a share of the profits, usually between 70–90%.
Other benefits include access to professional trading tools and the opportunity to develop a career in a professional trading environment. A potential downside is the pressure associated with adhering to strict risk management rules and the fees for participating in the qualification program.
Prop Trading Firms in the CFD Market
Currently, many Prop Trading firms specialize in the CFD segment. These firms provide access to a wide range of financial instruments, including currency pairs, indices, commodities, and stocks in the form of CFDs. They often collaborate with reputable brokers, ensuring traders access to liquidity and competitive trading conditions.
Offers from Prop Trading firms in the CFD market are highly popular due to their lower participation costs. The CFD market is characterized by relatively low costs, regardless of whether trading involves personal funds with a broker or working with a prop trading firm. Retail clients do not have to pay for data access, and most popular trading platforms are free for end-users.
Structure of Prop Trading Offers
In recent years, a standard two-stage challenge model has developed in the Prop Trading market. Increasing competition has led to some standardization of offers, making them easier to compare. A typical challenge consists of an evaluation and verification phase, where traders must demonstrate their skills by achieving specific profit goals while adhering to risk management rules.
A detailed analysis of the two-stage challenge shows that, in addition to the basic parameters outlined in the offer, hidden trading costs are also significant. Key factors include transaction fees, which can significantly affect trade results, especially for scalping or day trading strategies. Spreads, which vary between platforms, and swap costs for overnight positions also play a crucial role. These parameters are often not highlighted in the offers but can significantly impact overall trading profitability.
Criteria for Choosing a Prop Trading Firm
Credibility Based on Trader Reviews
A key source of information on the credibility of Prop Trading firms is reviews on platforms like Trustpilot. It is essential to pay attention not only to the overall rating but also to the content of reviews, particularly those concerning withdrawals and technical support. It is also worth checking whether the firm actively responds to negative reviews and how it resolves reported issues.
Moreover, while positive reviews can be "inspired" or even purchased, no one would intentionally post negative reviews about themselves. Therefore, special attention should be given to negative reviews, their frequency, the issues they address (serious problems or minor inconveniences), and the number of negative reviews within a month (keeping the firm's popularity in mind, as well-known firms may have more dissatisfied clients).
Experience in the Market
A firm’s longevity in the market is an important indicator of its stability and credibility. Companies operating for several years usually have established procedures, reliable support systems, and a solid reputation in the trading community. However, in the rapidly evolving Prop Trading sector, new and innovative firms may also offer attractive conditions while maintaining high security standards.
Comparing Price Offers
When analyzing price offers, it is important to focus on comparable basic parameters:
Profit targets of 10% for the challenge and 5% for verification.
Daily loss limits set at 5%.
Total loss limits at 10%.
A uniform method of calculating limits (e.g., static balance base).
Only with comparable parameters can one effectively assess which offer is more competitive. Some offers may appear cheaper but impose significant obstacles for traders, such as a lower Total Loss Limit or a Trailing Total Loss Limit.
Comparing Trading Conditions
Transaction Fees
Transaction fees are crucial, especially for traders using high-frequency trading strategies like scalping or day trading. For high daily transaction volumes, even a small difference in fees (e.g., $2 vs. $3 per lot) can significantly affect strategy profitability. For example, a trader executing 20 trades daily on one lot would incur an additional cost of $20 daily with a $1 fee difference, translating to $400 monthly.
Swap Rates
Swaps play an important role in medium- and long-term strategies where positions are held for days or weeks. Differences in swap rates between platforms can be significant, particularly for currency pairs with large interest rate differentials. For example, for a 1-lot position held for a month, a 1-point daily swap difference could result in an additional cost or profit of $300 monthly. It is especially important to check swap rates for currency pairs intended for long-term trading.
Spreads in Different Market Conditions
Spreads are variable trading costs that significantly impact transaction profitability. During peak liquidity hours (e.g., overlapping European and American sessions), spreads are usually lowest. However, during the release of critical economic data, nighttime hours, or low market liquidity, spreads can widen significantly. For traders in various time zones or those using automated trading systems, it is crucial to examine spreads under standard and reduced liquidity conditions.
Server Speed and Execution Quality
Order execution delays (latency) can be critical, particularly for strategies based on short-term price movements. Server speed impacts the precision of market entries and exits, which is especially important for scalping and algorithmic trading. Reliable Prop firms offer servers with latency below 50ms and stable connections, minimizing slippage and unexpected re-quotes.
Other Important Parameters
It is also worth considering:
Availability of various trading platforms (MT4, MT5, cTrader).
Maximum position sizes and limits on individual instruments.
The ability to trade during macroeconomic data releases.
Availability of technical analysis tools and trade automation options.
Customer support quality and response speed, especially in emergencies.
Summary
Choosing the right Prop Trading firm requires a comprehensive analysis of multiple factors. Beyond attractive challenge pricing and standard program parameters, actual trading conditions are crucial. For active traders, low transaction fees and fast order execution are paramount, while long-term strategies benefit from favorable swap rates and stable spreads.
We recommend creating a priority list based on the planned trading strategy and thoroughly comparing conditions among several leading providers. Testing the platform on a demo account is also advisable to verify order execution quality and platform stability under real market conditions.
Remember, the cheapest offer is not always the best—hidden trading costs can quickly offset the initial attractiveness of the challenge price. The key to success is finding a firm that offers the optimal balance between costs, trading conditions, and market stability and credibility.
Comments